Good news for charity trustees in the Kids Company High Court Decision.

The High Court has today ruled against the Official Receiver in its case for disqualification brought against the directors of the charity “Kids Company”, together with its CEO Camila Batmanghelidjh.

This is good news for those who are trustees / directors of charitable companies, as well as charity trustees more generally.

The Court decided that although the trustees / directors of a charitable company are subject to the same duties of other companies, the fact that “Kids Company” was a charity could not be ignored, and so reaffirmed the historical benevolence shown by the Court to charity trustees where there has been no dishonesty or intentional breach of duty.  

The Official Receiver had sought to argue that the trustees / directors were responsible for financial mismanagement, in that they had allowed the charity to operate an unsustainable business model. The primary purpose of an application to disqualify directors, as made by the Official Receiver here, was identified as being to protect the public.

The Court was of the opinion that the public, however, did not need any protection from the trustees / directors of “Kids Company”, who were described in the judgment as “a group of highly impressive and dedicated individuals who selflessly gave enormous amounts of their time to what was clearly a highly challenging trusteeship”.

Disqualification of any of the “Kids Company” trustees was unwarranted, the Court was “wholly satisfied”. It also decided that Camila Batmanghelidjh was not a de facto director, but that even if she had been such, no disqualification order would have been made against her in the circumstances.

The Court also noted that there was a risk that disqualification proceedings based on “wide ranging but unclear allegations of incompetence rather than any want of probity” were likely to discourage individuals from becoming charity trustees.

This is a judgment that will provide a great deal of comfort to the sector, given that there are, no doubt, many charity trustees at present being forced to make difficult financial decisions on behalf of their charities.

Similar Articles

Prevention of fraud ̵... You can take this preventative action now:  make sure charity software has up-to-date virus protection (though it will not always prevent you from becoming infected) 
The Data Protection Act ... This week, 2 charities have been found to be in breach of the Data Protection Act and have been issued with monetary penalties by the Information Commissioner.
London Olympics legacy f... More amateur sports charities have been set up and the sector’s income has increased in the years following the London 2012 Olympics, an analysis by the Charities
New rules disqualifying f... From 1 August 2018, new rules extend the criteria disqualifying certain individuals from acting as trustees or holding senior management positions in charities. The Charity Commission has
Press release from Charit... The Charity Commission, the regulator of charities in England and Wales, has published the findings of a study which has found that cultural factors, such as placing
Public can now demand tha... Charities which pester donors for cash face being fined up to £25,000 under new rules. A new Fundraising Preference Service, launched this week allows members of the
Welcome to our blog stay tuned for more information.
Guidance for trustees of... This guidance is for trustees of charities that have a long-term close relationship with a connected non-charitable organisation such as a: trading subsidiary commercial business not-for-profit organisation
Charities warned over man... The Charity Commission has said the public does not accept that charity bosses should receive salaries higher than the private sector. Public confidence and trust in charities
Charity accounts – ... The main reasons why charity accounts submissions do not meet the basic benchmark  are: failure to evidence that accounts had been subject to independent scrutiny by an

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *